Dear Flipper..
I will take these four:
Humans are just imperfect- they make mistakes
True. But these humans claim to be Spirit Directed, so is it really reasonable to believe God's Spirit allow them to make the kind of mistakes that would mislead and even kill thousands, for years before changing?? Example: Organ transplants, and Blood Fractions.
The holy spirit directed it , so it must be right
(I LOVE this one!!) Ask them to get out their dictionary and look up "directed", and the word "inspired". They will be most suprised that they both mean the same thing, and that is to be guided. So when they say..we are not inspired, but we are Spirit directed..it is simply a "play" on words. So to take it one step further..if they in fact are inspired, or being guided by the spirit..who keeps getting things wrong? Mere self appointed men? Or God's Holy Spirit??
Where else will we go ?
I have had several JWs throw this at me! They use this phrase from a scripture where one of the disciples is saying to Jesus.."who would we follow?" Not "Where would we go?" So when asked this, I have simply corrected them, by saying the scripture actually is talking about following Christ, not what "church" you had to belong to.
The light got brighter
(My FAVORITE!!) First of all this expression as used in the Scriptures has nothing to do with how it is applied by the JWs, if you read the context of the Scripture.
Second, if you used their "light gets brighter" reasoning, it would only work if something stayed the same. For example: We know from the scriptures God does not change, and we know he cannot lie. So.. if his Holy Spirit is truely guiding or directing the organization, policies that have been set in place from the onset of the organization , could never "flip flop" if he trely was guiding them. What was wrong would still be wrong, and what was right , would still be right.
Take for instance Blood. For years the policy was, it was to be poured out. You could not even use gardening products to keep the deer away that were made from "stored" blood, right?? But now..fractions are a conscience mattter. No longer a grave sin, worthy of disfellowshipping.
Ah... but they are fractions the JWs say. True. But you cannot sinthetically make fractions can you? The only way to make or get a fraction is from someone elses, STORED WHOLE BLOOD! Someone donated their blood, it was stored, and broken down all for someone else to use a fraction of it. And furthermore, why can JWs take fractions from stored blood, but cannot donate blood to be made into fractions for others??
Oh.. but the light gets "brighter, they say?? Well..something that was from God and considered wrong will be forever wrong in his eyes. Remember the scriptures say he CANNOT change. So, if the policy for no blood was truely from him, and we know he cannot change, then who exactly is doing the changing?? Couldn't it only be mere men, who are clearly not being guided by God??
Sincerely,
Lady Liberty